Mumbai, November 16 – In 2024, three of the six biggest Hindi films by India net were horror-comedies. Stree 2 finished the year at ₹597.99 Cr, Bhool Bhulaiyaa 3 at ₹260.11 Cr and Munjya at ₹102.54 Cr. Together they collected ₹960.64 Cr, about 61% of the combined net of the top six. Their combined budgets, as Sacnilk lists them, came to ₹305 Cr. The two action films in the same top six, Singham Again and Fighter, cost ₹575 Cr between them and collected ₹460.65 Cr.
The run has not stopped. In April 2026, Bhooth Bangla, Priyadarshan’s ghost comedy with Akshay Kumar, collected ₹182.36 Cr net and earned a SuperHit verdict from Sacnilk. The genre has also been a steady earner in Tamil for close to two decades, through Raghava Lawrence’s Kanchana films and Sundar C’s Aranmanai series. In 2025, a Kannada horror-comedy made by theatre actors, Su From So, opened on a handful of screens and finished at ₹92.33 Cr net.
The argument of this piece is that horror-comedy has become the most reliable genre in Indian cinema because of how it is built, not because ghosts are fashionable. The films are cheap to make by today’s standards. They do not need a superstar. They sell one ticket to a teenager and another to his grandmother for the same show. People come back to them, and they play as well in a small town as in a metro. That cost structure and audience mix give the genre a high floor and a very high ceiling.
The same data shows exactly where the formula breaks. When budgets and VFX bills swell, the margin that made the genre safe disappears. When a star’s price tag or a franchise plan becomes the reason for a film, the cheap, local, word-of-mouth engine stops working. The Raja Saab, a Telugu horror-comedy with a reported budget of over ₹300 Cr, collected ₹146.04 Cr net and is a Flop in Sacnilk’s records. Thamma, which Sacnilk lists at the same ₹125 Cr budget as Stree 2, opened big and faded fast. The genre is safe only for as long as it stays small.
Our earlier Editorial piece on sequels covered how Stree 2 grew about 4.6 times over the first film. This piece leaves those multiples aside and looks at the genre’s economics and its audience: what it costs, who buys the tickets, how long the films run, and why some of them fall flat.
The numbers behind the boom
Start with the 2024 Hindi chart, because it is the clearest picture of how far the genre has come. The table below lists the six highest-grossing Hindi films of that year by India net, with the budgets Sacnilk lists for each. Four of the six involve the supernatural, and three of those four are comedies.
Stree 2 alone collected more than Singham Again and Fighter combined. Bhool Bhulaiyaa 3, released on the same Diwali day as Singham Again, finished ahead of it on a budget less than half as large. Munjya, a film with no star in the lead, ended the year in the top six. Shaitaan, a straight horror film with a ₹60 Cr budget, sat just above it.
Take the top twelve Hindi films of 2024 in Sacnilk’s data and the three horror-comedies account for close to 48% of the group’s ₹2,008.80 Cr net. No other genre came close to that share. Action films had more stars, more screens and much bigger budgets. They did not have more return.
It would be easy to dismiss 2024 as one lucky year. The longer record says otherwise. Golmaal Again, Rohit Shetty’s Diwali 2017 film with a ghost at the centre of its plot, collected ₹205.69 Cr on a Sacnilk-listed budget of ₹80 Cr and is a Blockbuster. Bhool Bhulaiyaa 2 collected ₹184.32 Cr in May 2022, without the star of the original film. Thamma was the eighth-highest Hindi film of 2025 at ₹134.78 Cr. Bhooth Bangla is the seventh-highest Hindi film of 2026 by Hindi net so far.
A genre built on a cost sheet
The single most important number in a horror-comedy is the budget. The genre’s success rests on a simple piece of arithmetic: keep costs low and even an ordinary run turns a profit, while a word-of-mouth run turns into a windfall. The core exhibit below lists every major horror-comedy for which Sacnilk carries a budget, plus three with widely reported budgets, clearly labelled. The last ratio is India net divided by budget.
Budgets for Su From So, Bhooth Bangla and The Raja Saab are not set in Sacnilk’s database, so the table uses reported figures. Su From So’s ₹4.5 Cr production cost was stated by its producer Raj B Shetty, who said about ₹1 Cr more went on promotion and release. Bhooth Bangla’s ₹100-120 Cr is an estimate published by Business Today before release. The Raja Saab’s figure comes from a January 2026 report on the film’s losses, which put its budget at over ₹300 Cr.
Read the table from top to bottom and the pattern is plain. The films that returned four times their cost or more were all made for ₹30 Cr or less, with one exception. That exception, Stree 2, was a ₹125 Cr sequel to a ₹30 Cr film that had already built its audience. The films at the bottom fall into two groups. One is the small film that simply did not land, like Phone Bhoot and Roohi. The other is the expensive film that collected a respectable number and still failed to cover its cost, like Thamma and The Raja Saab.
A net-to-budget ratio is a rough tool. A producer does not take home the full India net. Exhibitors keep a large share of every ticket, and the producer’s recovery also includes overseas business, satellite and streaming rights and music. That is why Go Goa Gone is a Flop in Sacnilk’s records at 1.31 times its budget. A film needs well above 1x in theatres before it is in profit from the box office alone. On that reading, everything from Bhool Bhulaiyaa 3 upwards in the table made real money in cinemas, and the films at the bottom of the table leaned on non-theatrical income or lost money.
The important point is the shape of the risk. A horror-comedy that fails at ₹25 Cr loses a manageable sum. Phone Bhoot collected half its budget, which hurts, but the hole is small. An action spectacle that fails at ₹400 Cr can sink a studio’s year. War 2, a Flop on a ₹400 Cr budget, collected ₹236.55 Cr, far more than Phone Bhoot, and still lost much more money. Horror-comedy at its traditional price point offers a small downside and an open-ended upside. That is what reliability means in film finance.
No superstar required
The second pillar of the genre is that it does not depend on a single big name. Look at the leads of the most profitable Hindi horror-comedies. Stree starred Rajkummar Rao, Shraddha Kapoor, Pankaj Tripathi, Aparshakti Khurana and Abhishek Banerjee, an ensemble rather than a vehicle. Munjya’s credited leads in Sacnilk’s listing are Abhay Verma and Sharvari Wagh, with Mona Singh and Sathyaraj in support. The title character is a computer-generated ghost.
That matters for the cost sheet. In a star film, a large share of the budget goes to one person’s fee before a single scene is shot. In an ensemble horror-comedy, the money that would have gone to the star goes to the writing, the effects and the marketing, or it is never spent at all. Munjya’s director Aditya Sarpotdar has said about half its budget went to visual effects, made with the studio DNEG. On a ₹30 Cr film, that is still a modest effects bill by the standard of a big-star spectacle.
It also matters for the audience. When the hero is a character rather than a superstar, the film is sold on its premise and its jokes. A viewer does not need to be a fan of anyone to buy a ticket. That widens the potential audience, and it means the film’s fate rests on word of mouth rather than on a fan club’s opening-day turnout.
The Bhool Bhulaiyaa franchise shows this clearly. The 2007 original starred Akshay Kumar. The 2022 sequel had Kartik Aaryan in the lead and no Akshay at all, and it collected ₹184.32 Cr, nearly four times the original’s ₹49.11 Cr. The third film, also with Kartik, did ₹260.11 Cr. The brand, the haveli and the promise of laughs and scares carried the films more than any one actor did.
The Tamil and Kannada cases point the same way. Raghava Lawrence, the face of the Kanchana series, is its actor and director, and the films are sold on their formula as much as on his name. The Aranmanai films rest on Sundar C’s direction and an ensemble of comic actors. Su From So was led by its writer-director JP Thuminad and a cast drawn largely from theatre, with no major star at all.
There is a caveat. When a horror-comedy does cast a top star, it can still work, as Golmaal Again and Bhooth Bangla show. But the star then changes the economics. The film costs more, it opens bigger, and it has to earn more to break even. The genre’s built-in safety margin gets thinner with every crore added to the cast’s fees.
Two audiences in one ticket
The third pillar is the audience mix. A horror-comedy sells to two groups that Hindi cinema usually has to court separately: young viewers who want a scare with their friends, and families who want a comedy they can watch together. The comedy keeps the fear safe enough for parents and children. The horror gives teenagers and young adults a reason to go in a group and scream.
The certificates reflect this. Sacnilk lists Stree, Stree 2 and Bhooth Bangla with U/A certificates, which leave room for parents to bring children. Dhurandhar 2, the biggest Hindi hit of 2026, carries an A certificate in Sacnilk’s listing, which shuts out everyone under 18. A family outing for a horror-comedy is one booking that brings in four or five tickets.
Sacnilk’s footfall estimates give the clearest view of how wide this audience is. The table below divides each film’s India gross by Sacnilk’s estimated footfalls to get an average ticket price. A lower average usually means a bigger share of tickets sold at cheaper single screens, in smaller towns and on discounted days.
Two numbers stand out. Stree 2 sold an estimated 2.81 crore tickets. For comparison, Sacnilk estimates the Hindi versions of Pushpa 2 and Dhurandhar 2, two of the biggest films ever in the Hindi market, at about 3.88 crore and 3.87 crore footfalls. A ₹125 Cr horror-comedy with no superstar sold about 72% as many Hindi tickets as those two event films.
The second is Bhooth Bangla. It collected ₹78 Cr less net than Bhool Bhulaiyaa 3, yet Sacnilk estimates it sold more tickets, 1.03 crore against 93.0 lakh. Its average ticket of ₹209 is the lowest of any big Hindi horror-comedy in the table. Bhool Bhulaiyaa 3 played to a Diwali audience paying festival prices. Bhooth Bangla played for weeks to a wider, more price-sensitive crowd.
The day-wise data shows where that crowd came from. On Bhooth Bangla’s second Monday, Sacnilk estimates about 2.0 lakh footfalls at an average gross ticket of roughly ₹204. On the Tuesday that followed, footfalls jumped to about 3.57 lakh while the average ticket fell to about ₹140. Net collections rose only from ₹3.50 Cr to ₹4.35 Cr. Thamma shows the same Tuesday pattern in its third week. These are viewers who wait for the cheaper day, and a family horror-comedy is the kind of film they wait for.
This price-sensitive audience is also the one that sustains the genre beyond the metros. A film that appeals mainly to premium multiplex audiences in big cities runs out of new buyers quickly. A film that a family in a small town will watch on a discounted Tuesday has a much longer runway.
Legs: why horror-comedies keep selling in week three
If the cost sheet is the first secret of the genre, its legs are the second. A horror-comedy that works rarely makes most of its money on the first weekend. It grows as people tell each other about the jokes and the scares, and it holds through the second and third weekends. The table below measures this by dividing each film’s lifetime India net by its opening day, as Sacnilk records it.
Munjya is the purest example of how the genre is meant to work. It opened at ₹4.00 Cr on June 7, 2024, a modest number for any Hindi film. Its second Sunday, at ₹8.50 Cr, was higher than its first Sunday at ₹8.00 Cr. Its second week, at ₹32.65 Cr, was more than 92% of its first week. It made only about a third of its lifetime in week one and finished at more than 25 times its opening day.
Munjya’s run also shows what ends a horror-comedy’s run: a bigger film. On its 21st day, Thursday June 27, its collection fell from ₹2.25 Cr the day before to ₹0.85 Cr. That was the day Kalki 2898 AD released and took over screens across the country. A small film that relies on staying in cinemas for weeks is always exposed to the next big release.
Stree followed a similar path in 2018. It opened at ₹6.82 Cr and climbed to ₹14.57 Cr by its first Sunday. It finished at 19 times its opening day. Stree 2 was a much bigger opener, at ₹51.80 Cr on the Independence Day holiday with 12,211 shows and 70% occupancy in Sacnilk’s tracking. Even then its first Sunday, at ₹55.90 Cr, beat its opening day, and it went on to 11.5 times its first day. That is a very long run for a film that opened that big.
Now look at the bottom of the table. Thamma opened at ₹24.00 Cr on October 21, 2025, nearly six times Munjya’s opening, in the Diwali window. Its Hindi version took about 70% of its lifetime in the first week. The Raja Saab opened at ₹62.90 Cr including paid previews and took about 89% of its lifetime in eight days. By its second Friday it was down to 3,476 shows from 16,470 on its first day. These films behaved like event films, not like horror-comedies. They had big openings bought by marketing, star power and festival timing, and they lacked the word of mouth that carries the genre’s best titles.
The legs table also explains the budget table. A ₹30 Cr film with 25x legs ends up with a huge return. A ₹125 Cr film with 5.6x legs ends up roughly at its budget. The money is made in weeks two, three and four, and those weeks only come if the film delivers what the genre promises.
From Go Goa Gone to Chanderi: how the Maddock model was built
The Hindi horror-comedy boom has a clear starting point, and it was a Flop. Go Goa Gone, released on May 10, 2013, was directed by Raj & DK and produced by Saif Ali Khan and Dinesh Vijan, among others. It was marketed as India’s first zombie comedy. It cost ₹19 Cr and collected ₹24.98 Cr, which in Sacnilk’s records is a Flop.
The people behind it learned from it. Amar Kaushik, who had been a first assistant director on Go Goa Gone, made his debut as a director with Stree in 2018. Raj & DK wrote the story and screenplay. Dinesh Vijan produced through Maddock Films. The difference was the source. Go Goa Gone borrowed a Western idea, zombies. Stree borrowed an Indian one.
Stree is loosely based on the urban legend of Nale Ba, which means “come tomorrow” in Kannada. The legend, tied to Karnataka, told of a spirit that would turn away from a house if it found the words written on the door. Raj & DK found the idea of a ghost turning back after reading a sign both absurd and funny. They reversed the gender so the ghost targets men, and set the film in Chanderi in Madhya Pradesh, where filming began on January 13, 2018.
That choice of setting is part of the economics. Chanderi is a small town with old buildings, narrow lanes and a strong local identity. It looks like the places much of the audience lives in or comes from. A ghost story set there feels close to home in a way that a story set in a Mumbai high-rise does not. It also costs far less to shoot in a real small town than to build a fantasy world on a stage.
The films that followed kept going back to regional folklore. Bhediya was set in Ziro in Arunachal Pradesh and drew on local folklore about a Yapum, a shape-shifting creature that protects the forest. Munjya came from the Konkan coast of Maharashtra. In that tradition, a munjya is the restless ghost of a boy who died after his thread ceremony but before marriage, and it lives in a peepal tree. The film was shot in Kudal and Guhagar in the Konkan.
Thamma drew on the folklore of the Betaal, or vetala, which most Indian viewers know from the Vikram-Betaal stories. In Maddock’s version, the Betaals are a clan of vampire-like beings. That was the point where the films began to move away from a single village legend and towards a mythology built for a franchise.
Folklore works for the genre in three ways. It gives the audience a hook they already half-know, which makes the premise easy to sell in a single line. It gives the writers a set of local rules to play with, which is where much of the comedy comes from. And it keeps the films rooted in specific places, which is good for the small-town audience the genre depends on.
Bhool Bhulaiyaa and the Manichitrathazhu family
The Bhool Bhulaiyaa franchise has a longer history than its Hindi numbers suggest. The 2007 film was Priyadarshan’s Hindi remake of Manichitrathazhu, the Malayalam film directed by Fazil and released on December 25, 1993. Written by Madhu Muttam, it starred Mohanlal, Shobana and Suresh Gopi. Shobana won the National Award for Best Actress for her role as Ganga and Nagavalli. Priyadarshan had worked on the original as one of three second-unit directors who shot alongside Fazil to speed up filming.
Manichitrathazhu was inspired by a real tragedy in the Alummoottil family at Muttom, near Haripad, and the local legends that grew around it. It was the highest-grossing Malayalam film at the time, with a reported ₹6.88 Cr from its first run. It returned to cinemas in a 4K version in August 2024, more than thirty years after its release. Few Indian films have travelled as far as this one.
Before the Hindi version, the story had already been remade as Apthamitra in Kannada in 2004, and as Chandramukhi in Tamil and Rajmohol in Bengali in 2005. Bhool Bhulaiyaa arrived in October 2007 and collected ₹49.11 Cr net on a ₹32 Cr budget, a SuperHit in Sacnilk’s records. One Malayalam script had been made in five languages. That tells you how well the basic idea, a haunted family house with a psychological twist and a comic outsider, crosses language lines when it is remade with local actors and local humour.
The later Hindi films kept the title and the haveli and changed almost everything else. Bhool Bhulaiyaa 2 and 3 are original stories, not remakes. They proved the brand had value on its own. The Tamil line did not hold up as well. Chandramukhi 2, released in 2023, collected ₹39.21 Cr net, a reminder that a famous title alone does not make a hit.
Priyadarshan returned to the genre in 2026 with Bhooth Bangla, reuniting with Akshay Kumar after 16 years. The film released on April 17, 2026, after paid previews on April 16. It collected ₹182.36 Cr net and is a SuperHit in Sacnilk’s records. It did this in the same spring that Dhurandhar 2 was dominating Hindi screens. A ghost comedy from two veterans of the genre found an audience that a spy action saga was not serving.
Bhooth Bangla also shows how a star changes the shape of a horror-comedy run without breaking it. Its opening day, including previews, was ₹16.00 Cr, more than double Stree’s. It still went on to more than 11 times that opening, with second-weekend collections of ₹10.75 Cr and ₹12.50 Cr on Saturday and Sunday. The star bought it a stronger start. The genre gave it the legs.
The Tamil franchise factory: Kanchana and Aranmanai
Long before Stree, Tamil cinema had turned horror-comedy into a dependable franchise business. Raghava Lawrence’s series began with Muni in 2007, which was made for a reported ₹4 Cr and collected a reported ₹15 Cr. Kanchana followed in 2011, reportedly made for ₹7 Cr and collecting about ₹60 Cr. Kanchana 2 in 2015 reportedly cost ₹18 Cr and collected about ₹108 Cr, with its Telugu version, Ganga, opening on about 550 screens.
The fourth film, Kanchana 3, released on April 19, 2019, is the first in the series with full figures in Sacnilk’s database. It collected ₹97.65 Cr net and ₹130.20 Cr worldwide on a Sacnilk-listed budget of ₹40 Cr. Sacnilk rates both its Tamil and Telugu versions as Blockbusters. The Tamil version did ₹67.05 Cr and the Telugu version ₹30.60 Cr, about 31% of the film’s India net.
That Telugu share is important. Horror-comedy is usually hard to dub, because so much of the comedy is in the language. Kanchana has built a Telugu following through its dubbed versions since Ganga in 2015, and the films’ broad, physical comedy works across the two languages. The Hindi remake of Kanchana, Laxmii, directed by Lawrence with Akshay Kumar, released in November 2020, during the pandemic, and went to streaming in India. Sacnilk records no Indian theatrical collection for it, only ₹4.08 Cr from overseas cinemas.
Sundar C’s Aranmanai series has run on a similar model. The third film came in October 2021. Aranmanai 4, released on May 3, 2024, with Tamannaah Bhatia and Raashii Khanna, was described as the first major Tamil hit of 2024, ending a five-month dry spell for the industry. Sacnilk reported at the time that it had become the highest-grossing Tamil film of the year at the worldwide box office, overtaking Ayalaan.
Aranmanai 4 finished at ₹67.99 Cr net and ₹98.75 Cr worldwide. The Tamil version did ₹60.23 Cr, Telugu ₹5.86 Cr and Hindi ₹1.90 Cr. Sacnilk’s report from May 2024 noted that its predecessor had grossed an estimated ₹30-40 Cr worldwide, and the first two films about ₹40 Cr combined. The fourth film was the biggest in the series by a wide margin.
Both Tamil franchises are coming back. Kanchana 4, with Pooja Hegde and Nora Fatehi, began filming in Chennai in January 2025. A January 2026 report said about 70% of it had been shot and that it was expected before the end of 2026. The same report said Sundar C would start Aranmanai 5 after finishing his current film. Neither title had a confirmed release date in Sacnilk’s listings at the time of writing.
The Tamil model is worth studying because it predates the Hindi boom and has survived much longer. Each film is a fresh story with a familiar shape: a big house or a possessed hero, a group of comic actors, a female ghost with a reason for revenge, and a festive climax. The budgets have risen slowly. The audience knows exactly what it is buying, and it keeps buying it.
Small films, big multiples: the regional edge
The best returns in the genre in recent years have come from Malayalam and Kannada, from films so cheap that even a modest hit becomes a large multiple. Romancham, Jithu Madhavan’s debut, released on February 3, 2023, in 144 theatres in Kerala. It was based on his own college days: seven bachelors in a Bengaluru hostel in 2007 try to summon a spirit with a Ouija board. Sacnilk lists its budget at ₹5 Cr. It collected ₹38.73 Cr net and ₹69.00 Cr worldwide, a Blockbuster.
About a third of Romancham’s worldwide total, ₹23.30 Cr, came from overseas, largely from Malayali audiences abroad. That is a reminder that a regional horror-comedy can find a second market abroad without any dubbing at all. Its audience is defined by language and culture, not by geography.
Su From So followed a year and a half later in Kannada. It opened on July 25, 2025, on about 13 screens in Karnataka, against the advice of distributors who worried about three big films opening in other languages that day. Paid premieres in several cities had already filled up, and word of mouth spread fast. Within seven days it was on about 150 screens. In Bengaluru alone, its shows grew from 70 on the first day to 180 on the second and 340 on the third.
The film is set in a coastal village in Dakshina Kannada, where a young man’s crush turns into rumours that he is possessed by a ghost named Sulochana. Its writer-director, JP Thuminad, comes from Tulu theatre and cinema, and most of the cast came from the stage. Sacnilk records ₹92.33 Cr net, with ₹84.45 Cr from the Kannada version, and rates it a Blockbuster. On the reported ₹4.5 Cr production cost, that is about 20 times its budget.
Su From So’s dubbed versions made only a small mark. Its Malayalam version, released on August 1, collected ₹5.65 Cr, and its Telugu version ₹2.23 Cr. The same is true of most horror-comedies. Bhediya’s Telugu and Tamil versions together made ₹0.33 Cr. Thamma’s Telugu version made ₹0.90 Cr. Aranmanai 4’s Hindi version made ₹1.90 Cr. Horror travels, but the jokes do not, and the genre’s money stays mostly in its home language.
Remakes do not solve this either, unless they are made with care. The Hindi remake of Romancham, Kapkapiii, released on May 23, 2025, and collected ₹1.50 Cr net in Sacnilk’s records. The original had collected more than 25 times that in Malayalam. A premise can be bought. The specific voice that made audiences laugh cannot.
Marathi cinema has also produced its own horror-comedies. Tumbadchi Manjula, a 2026 village ghost comedy, has collected ₹16.47 Cr net in Sacnilk’s records. Aditya Sarpotdar, who directed Munjya and Thamma, also made the ZEE5 horror-comedy Kakuda, which premiered on streaming on July 12, 2024, after first being planned for cinemas. The genre’s talent pool now moves easily between languages and formats.
Where the formula breaks: budgets, VFX and The Raja Saab
The clearest warning in the data is The Raja Saab. It was a Telugu horror-comedy led by Prabhas, with Sanjay Dutt and Boman Irani, directed by Maruthi. Maruthi pitched the script to Prabhas in 2022. Its release was first set for April 10, 2025, then December 5, 2025, and was pushed back more than once because post-production was not finished. Its effects work alone ran to nearly 300 days. It finally released on January 9, 2026, for the Sankranti holiday.
The opening was huge. Sacnilk records ₹9.15 Cr from paid previews and ₹53.75 Cr on the first day, on 16,470 shows. But occupancy on that first day was 33.4% in Sacnilk’s tracking, less than half of Stree 2’s 70% on its opening. The film had been placed on far more screens than its demand could fill. By the second day collections had fallen by more than half, and the first week ended at ₹130.25 Cr, about 89% of its final ₹146.04 Cr.
On a reported budget of over ₹300 Cr, ₹146.04 Cr net is a heavy loss, and Sacnilk rates the film a Flop. It reached streaming on February 6, 2026, less than a month after release. The Raja Saab sold an estimated 63.4 lakh tickets across languages. That is far more than Munjya, and a large audience by any normal measure. It was simply not enough for a film that cost ten times as much.
The problem was not the genre. It was everything the film added to the genre. A pan-India star’s fee, a long production, a heavy effects bill and a five-language release turned a horror-comedy into a spectacle. A spectacle needs a spectacle’s audience. The jokes and scares that sell a ₹30 Cr film by word of mouth had to carry a ₹300 Cr film from the first show, and they could not.
The Hindi slate has its own version of this warning. Bhediya leaned heavily on effects, with a transforming werewolf as its central image. Its budget, at ₹60 Cr, was twice Stree’s. It collected ₹68.99 Cr, an Average in Sacnilk’s records. The effects did not bring a bigger audience. They only raised the cost of reaching the same one.
Effects are not always the enemy. Munjya spent about half its ₹30 Cr budget on visual effects and turned its effects-made ghost into a selling point. The difference is proportion. On a small film, effects are one tool among many. On a big film, they become the reason for the budget and, too often, the reason for the delay.
When the universe takes over
Thamma is the most instructive case, because it came from the most successful team in the genre. Maddock had made Stree for ₹30 Cr and Munjya for ₹30 Cr. Thamma, released on October 21, 2025, carried a Sacnilk-listed budget of ₹125 Cr, the same as Stree 2. It starred Ayushmann Khurrana and Rashmika Mandanna, with Nawazuddin Siddiqui and Paresh Rawal. Varun Dhawan made a cameo as Bhediya, and Nora Fatehi appeared as a character from Stree. It was built to connect to the universe at every turn.
The opening was strong at ₹24.00 Cr, and the film reached ₹134.78 Cr net. By the standard of most Hindi films that is a solid number, and it was the eighth-highest Hindi film of 2025. But it was barely above its budget, and Sacnilk has not assigned it a verdict. Reviews were mixed, and several critics said it had far less horror than the earlier films. Its run behaved like a franchise film living off its opening, not like a horror-comedy growing on word of mouth.
Read against Munjya, Thamma is a lesson in what a universe can and cannot do. The universe gave Thamma an opening six times larger than Munjya’s. It did not give it Munjya’s legs. Thamma cost four times as much and collected about 1.3 times as much. The cross-overs, the cameos and the bigger cast raised awareness and cost. The story was what audiences talked about, and the talk was not as good.
Maddock’s own plans show how much the company has bet on the universe. In January 2025, it announced eight films through 2028: Thamma for Diwali 2025, Shakti Shalini for December 31, 2025, Bhediya 2 for August 14, 2026, Chamunda for December 4, 2026, Stree 3 for August 13, 2027, Mahamunjya for December 24, 2027, and a two-part finale, Pehla Mahayudh on August 11, 2028 and Doosara Mahayudh on October 18, 2028. Dinesh Vijan said at the time that the company was only getting started.
The dates have already slipped. Shakti Shalini was pushed back by about a year in 2025, with Aneet Padda later cast in the lead. A March 2026 report said it was in production and slated for December 24, 2026. Bhediya 2’s August 14, 2026 date has passed without a release, and Sacnilk’s listing for the film carries no date. A 2025 report said Chamunda was still being scripted, with no director attached. In October 2025, Vijan said Stree 3 would not come in 2026 because the team was taking its time and did not want to repeat itself.
That last remark is the right instinct. The genre’s best films came from a story first and a franchise second. Stree was a one-off ghost comedy that happened to be good enough to build on. The risk for the universe is that the order gets reversed, with films made to fill a slot on a timeline and to lead into a crossover, and the budgets rising to match.
The counter-argument: is the boom really just Stree?
There is a fair case against the thesis of this piece. Remove Stree 2 from the Hindi numbers, and the boom looks much smaller. Stree 2’s ₹597.99 Cr is more than the combined net of Stree, Bhediya, Munjya and Thamma. One film that became a cultural event can distort the picture of a whole genre.
The failures are also real. Phone Bhoot collected ₹12.81 Cr on a ₹25 Cr budget. Roohi collected ₹21.93 Cr on ₹25 Cr. The Bhootnii, a 2025 horror-comedy, collected ₹9.57 Cr. Kapkapiii collected ₹1.50 Cr. Go Goa Gone was a Flop. Kakuda and Laxmii never reached Indian cinemas at all. For every Munjya there is at least one ghost comedy that sank without much notice. A reader who only sees the hits is seeing a filtered picture.
There is also a timing argument. Roohi released in March 2021, when cinemas were still recovering from the pandemic. Bhool Bhulaiyaa 2 came in 2022, while Hindi cinema was still rebuilding its audience after the pandemic. Stree 2 had the Independence Day holiday, Bhool Bhulaiyaa 3 had Diwali. Some of the genre’s success is the success of good release dates.
Each of these points has weight, but none of them overturns the central claim. Reliability in this business does not mean every film works. It means the losses are small when a film fails and the gains are large when it works. Phone Bhoot’s loss was bounded by its ₹25 Cr budget. Even the weak Hindi entries in the table lost a fraction of what a failed action spectacle loses. Across the films with Sacnilk-listed budgets in our table, the twelve Hindi horror-comedies cost ₹781 Cr together and collected ₹1,793.08 Cr net, about 2.3 times their combined budgets. Take Stree 2 out and the other eleven still collected ₹1,195.09 Cr on ₹656 Cr of budgets, about 1.8 times.
The release-date argument cuts both ways. Munjya released in early June with no holiday and still found its audience over weeks. Su From So released on 13 screens against three big films. Romancham released in February. The holiday helps a horror-comedy, as it helps any family film, but the best results in the genre have come from films that earned their run rather than bought it with a date.
The fairest reading of the counter-argument is that it describes the conditions under which the genre stops being reliable. The flops in the list mostly lacked the strong local premise and the comic writing that word of mouth needs. The expensive misfires had the opposite problem: too much money and too little story. That is the thesis restated, not refuted.
What keeps the genre working
Put the evidence together and a clear set of rules comes out of it. The first is to keep the budget in proportion. The films that returned three times their cost or more in Sacnilk’s data were mostly made for ₹30 Cr or less, or, like Stree 2, built on a cheap original that had already done the hard work. Each step up in cost moves a horror-comedy closer to needing an event-film opening, which the genre is not designed to deliver.
The second rule is to cast an ensemble, not a price tag. Stars can help, as Bhooth Bangla showed, but the genre’s margin depends on the money not going to one fee. Rajkummar Rao and Pankaj Tripathi in a small town are worth more to a horror-comedy than any amount of spectacle.
The third is to stay local. Chanderi, the Konkan, the hostels of Bengaluru and the villages of Dakshina Kannada gave these films their texture and their audience. The comedy comes from people the audience recognises, speaking the way they speak. That is also why the genre dubs poorly and remakes badly, and why its money stays largely in its home language.
The fourth is to make a film that people want to talk about. The genre’s economics depend on weeks two, three and four. Munjya’s second Sunday beat its first. Stree 2’s first Sunday beat its record opening day. The Raja Saab’s second day fell by more than half. No marketing budget replaces the conversation after the show.
The fifth is to treat a universe as a reward, not a plan. Maddock’s slate through 2028 is the most ambitious bet on the genre that Indian cinema has seen. The early evidence from Thamma suggests that crossovers and cameos raise openings but do not create legs. Vijan’s decision to take more time over Stree 3 is the sort of discipline the genre needs. Kanchana 4 and Aranmanai 5 will test the same question in Tamil.
Horror-comedy became Indian cinema’s most reliable genre because it fits the way most Indians go to the movies: in groups, as families, on a budget, to laugh and scream together at a story set somewhere that looks like home. It works when it is cheap, local, star-light and good enough to be talked about. It fails when it forgets those things and tries to become a spectacle. The next two years of releases, from Shakti Shalini to Kanchana 4, will show whether the industry has learned the difference.
Stay tuned…
