‘Asian Games, England, Ireland, now Ranchi’: Dinesh Karthik exposes India’s hidden fielding crisis ahead of 2027 World Cup originally appeared on Cricket News. Add Cricket News as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
KEY TAKEAWAYS:
-
Former India wicketkeeper Dinesh Karthik has warned that the fielding standards have slipped badly, and that the problem could hurt them at the 2027 ODI World Cup.
-
After the six-wicket loss in Ranchi, Karthik said the lapses in Asian Games, England and Ireland were hidden by wins, with new coach Subhadeep Ghosh now under scrutiny.
-
India have a busy run of series before the World Cup, which starts on October 2, 2027, to repair their catching and positioning.
Advertisement
‘Look at yourself if you can’t defend 249’: Dinesh Karthik sounds alarm over India’s fielding crisis after Ranchi defeat to West Indies
India’s fielding has been slipping for months, and Dinesh Karthik believes the six-wicket defeat to West Indies in Ranchi has finally highlighted the problem. The former wicketkeeper has warned that the team must lift its standards in the field if it hopes to win major tournaments, and with the 2027 ODI World Cup drawing closer, the time available to fix the issue is shrinking fast.
India lost the second T20I against the Caribbean despite posting a formidable 249/5 on the back of Sanju Samson’s 82 off 41 balls. The visitors still chased the target down with nine balls to spare, as Shai Hope struck an unbeaten 102 off 45 deliveries and Sherfane Rutherford added 84 off 37 balls.
Karthik did not suggest the target was out of reach for a side with India’s resources, and he moved quickly to the real concern.
Advertisement
Speaking to Cricbuzz, he said: “No doubt, 249. If you start thinking it’s going to be a hard match, then you really need to look at yourself. But fielding has been an issue for some time now. Because we have won the ODI series and the Asian Games, it has gone a bit unnoticed.”
He then listed the occasions on which the fielding had fallen short, which stretched well beyond one bad night in Ranchi.
“But even in the final of the Asian Games, they didn’t field well. In England, they didn’t field well. In Ireland, they didn’t field well either. So, it has been an issue,” Karthik said.
Subhadeep Ghosh faces a testing assignment as India fielding coach
India appointed Subhadeep Ghosh as the men’s team fielding coach in August 2026, after the BCCI decided not to renew the contract of T Dilip. Ghosh has previously worked with India A and Andhra, and he is now expected to fix the lapses that have repeatedly cost the team. Karthik believes the change itself says something about the board’s thinking.
Advertisement
“They have let go of the previous fielding coach, and I’m sure it has come at a point when they felt he wasn’t able to get the team to the next level,” he said.
“Now, it is Shubhadeep Ghosh, the newly appointed fielding coach, and I think he will be under the scanner. Your job is to make sure Team India fields better than it did before. If you’re not able to do that, you will face the heat.”
Karthik was careful to praise the newcomer’s background, although he made it clear the job carries heavy pressure.
“Being part of Team India is always a challenge, and he’s a talented fielding coach. He’s been around the block for some time now, having been part of the India A team. He was also the fielding coach of the Andhra team,” he said.
Advertisement
The former India keeper also pointed to two specific areas for the new coach, namely the positioning of the fast bowlers and their ability to hold on to chances.
“I think he should figure out a way to get the pacers to stand in the right positions and make sure they hold on to their catches,” Karthik added.
Ranchi supplied a fresh example as Mayank Yadav dropped Rutherford when the batter was on 38, and the reprieve allowed him to continue an innings that eventually transformed the chase. He went on to put together a 120-run stand for the fourth wicket with Hope, which proved the turning point.
The concern is not limited to outside observers, as captain Shubman Gill has reportedly acknowledged it as well. After the third ODI against West Indies in Mullanpur, he conceded that dropped catches and untidy work in the field had hurt India during the series, even though the hosts won it 2-1.
Advertisement
In that final game, West Indies chased down India’s 351/7 to win by five wickets, with Hope finishing unbeaten on 162.
“But, in general, you have to say that Team India’s fielding standards have dropped, for sure, in the last couple of months. They will need to pick it up because it’s an important aspect if they want to win the big tournaments as well,” Karthik added.
India’s next chance to improve comes in the rest of the West Indies T20I series, followed by a multi-format tour of New Zealand in October and November, which is understood to include five T20Is, five ODIs and two Tests. ODI series against Sri Lanka in December and Zimbabwe in January 2027 will follow.
The ICC World Cup begins on October 2, 2027, and India are scheduled to meet Australia on October 7 and Pakistan on October 10 in the group stage.
Advertisement
Fielding is the cheapest fix India are ignoring
Karthik’s warning deserves attention, because fielding is the one department where improvement depends on effort and not on talent. India have no shortage of batting depth or bowling options, yet a few dropped catches can undo all of that in a single evening, as Ranchi showed when Rutherford was let off on 38 and went on to wreck the chase.
The more troubling point is how long the problem has been hidden. Victories in the Asian Games and an ODI series win helped to cover weak fielding in the final, in England and in Ireland, and a team that keeps winning rarely feels the urge to change. That comfort is exactly what proves dangerous in a knockout tournament, where one missed chance can end a campaign.
Subhadeep Ghosh should be given a fair amount of time, however, because a coach who joined in August can’t be blamed for months of poor habits. What the management can do is make fielding standards part of selection, with clear drills for the pacers on positioning and regular catching practice in match conditions.
Advertisement
India have a packed schedule before the World Cup, which is a useful opportunity as much as a heavy workload. If the team treats every series as a chance to tighten up, the problem can be fixed in time. If it doesn’t, the same lapses will reappear when the margins are at their finest.
To keep up to date with all the latest cricket news and share your opinion on the biggest topics visit ourFacebook, Instagram and X (Twitter) pages.
